Calendar No. 85
[Report No. 111–33]
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
May 4, 2009
Mr. Kerry (for himself, Mr. Lugar, Mr. Kaufman, Mr. Durbin, Mr. Casey, Mr. Carper, Mr. Whitehouse, Mr. Burris, Mr. Cardin, Mrs. Gillibrand, Mrs. Shaheen, and Mr. Dodd) introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred to the Committee on Foreign Relations
June 23, 2009
Reported by Mr. Kerry, with amendments
Omit the part struck through and insert the part printed in italic
To authorize appropriations for fiscal years 2009 through 2013 to promote an enhanced strategic partnership with Pakistan and its people, and for other purposes.
This Act may be cited as
Enhanced Partnership with Pakistan
Act of 2009.
Congress makes the following findings:
The people of Pakistan and the United States have a long history of friendship and comity, and the interests of both nations are well-served by strengthening and deepening this friendship.
In February 2008, the people of Pakistan elected a civilian government, reversing years of political tension and mounting popular concern over governance and their own democratic reform and political development.
A democratic, moderate, modernizing Pakistan would represent the wishes of the Pakistani people and serve as a model to other countries around the world.
Economic growth is a fundamental foundation for human security and national stability in Pakistan, a country with over 175,000,000 people, an annual population growth rate of 2 percent, and a ranking of 136 out of 177 countries in the United Nations Human Development Index.
Pakistan is a major non-NATO ally of the United States and has been a valuable partner in the battle against al Qaeda and the Taliban, but much more remains to be accomplished by both nations.
The struggle against al Qaeda, the Taliban, and affiliated terrorist groups has led to the deaths of several thousand Pakistani civilians and members of the security forces of Pakistan over the past 7 years.
Since the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, more al Qaeda terrorist suspects have been apprehended in Pakistan than in any other country, including Khalid Sheikh Muhammad, Ramzi bin al-Shibh, and Abu Faraj al-Libi.
Despite the sacrifices and cooperation of the security forces of Pakistan, the top leadership of al Qaeda, as well as the leadership and rank-and-file of affiliated terrorist groups, are believed to be using Pakistan’s Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) and parts of the North West Frontier Province (NWFP) and Balochistan as a haven and a base from which to organize terrorist actions in Pakistan and globally, including—
attacks outside of Pakistan that have been attributed to groups with Pakistani connections, including—
the suicide car bombing of the Indian embassy in Kabul, Afghanistan, which killed 58 people on June 7, 2008; and
the massacre of approximately 165 people in Mumbai, India, including 6 United States citizens, in late November 2008; and
attacks within Pakistan, including—
an attack on the visiting Sri Lankan cricket team in Lahore on March 3, 2009;
an attack at the Marriott hotel in Islamabad on September 9, 2008;
the bombing of a political rally in Karachi on October 18, 2007;
the targeting and killing of dozens of tribal, provincial, and national holders of political office;
an attack by gunfire on the U.S. Principal Officer in Peshawar in August 2008; and
the brazen assassination of former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto on December 27, 2007.
In the 12-month period ending on the date of the enactment of this Act, Pakistan’s security forces have struggled to contain a Taliban-backed insurgency that has spread from FATA into settled areas, including the Swat Valley and other parts of NWFP and Balochistan. This struggle has taken the lives of more than 1,500 police and military personnel and left more than 3,000 wounded.
On March 27,
2009, President Obama noted,
Multiple intelligence estimates have warned
that al Qaeda is actively planning attacks on the U.S. homeland from its
safe-haven in Pakistan..
According to a
Government Accountability Office Report (GAO–08–622),
since 2003, the
administration’s national security strategies and Congress have recognized that
a comprehensive plan that includes all elements of national power—diplomatic,
military, intelligence, development assistance, economic, and law enforcement
support—was needed to address the terrorist threat emanating from the
FATA and that such a strategy was also mandated by section 7102(b)(3)
of the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004 (Public Law
108–458; 22 U.S.C. 2656f note) and section 2042(b)(2) of the Implementing the
Recommendations of the 9/11 Commission Act of 2007 (Public Law 110–53; 22
U.S.C. 2375 note).
In the past year, the people of Pakistan have been especially hard hit by rising food and commodity prices and severe energy shortages, with two-thirds of the population living on less than $2 a day and one-fifth of the population living below the poverty line according to the United Nations Development Program.
The people of Pakistan and the United States share many compatible goals, including—
combating terrorism and violent radicalism, both inside Pakistan and elsewhere;
solidifying democracy and the rule of law in Pakistan;
promoting the economic development of Pakistan, both through the building of infrastructure and the facilitation of increased trade;
promoting the social and material well-being of Pakistani citizens, particularly through development of such basic services as public education, access to potable water, and medical treatment; and
safeguarding the peace and security of South Asia, including by facilitating peaceful relations between Pakistan and its neighbors.
According to consistent opinion research, including that of the Pew Global Attitudes Survey (December 28, 2007) and the International Republican Institute (January 29, 2008), many people in Pakistan have historically viewed the relationship between the United States and Pakistan as a transactional one, characterized by a heavy emphasis on security issues with little attention to other matters of great interest to citizens of Pakistan.
The election of a civilian government in Pakistan in February 2008 provides an opportunity, after nearly a decade of military-dominated rule, to place relations between Pakistan and the United States on a new and more stable foundation.
Both the Government of Pakistan and the United States Government should seek to enhance the bilateral relationship through additional multi-faceted engagement in order to strengthen the foundation for a consistent and reliable long-term partnership between the two countries.
In this Act:
Appropriate congressional committees
The term appropriate congressional committees means the Committees on Appropriations and Foreign Relations of the Senate and the Committees on Appropriations and Foreign Affairs of the House of Representatives.
The term counterinsurgency means efforts to defeat organized movements that seek to overthrow the duly constituted Governments of Pakistan and Afghanistan through violent means.
The term counterterrorism means efforts to combat al Qaeda and other foreign terrorist organizations that are designated by the Secretary of State in accordance with section 219 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1189), or other individuals and entities engaged in terrorist activity or support for such activity.
The term FATA means the Federally Administered Tribal Areas of Pakistan.
The term NWFP means the North West Frontier Province of Pakistan, which has Peshawar as its provincial capital.
Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas
The term Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas includes the Pakistan regions known as NWFP, FATA, and parts of Balochistan in which the Taliban or Al Qaeda have traditionally found refuge.
The term security-related assistance means—
grant assistance to carry out section 23 of the Arms Export Control Act (22 U.S.C. 2763);
assistance under chapter 2 of part II of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (22 U.S.C. 2311 et seq.);
assistance under chapter 5 of part II of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (22 U.S.C. 2347 et seq.);
any equipment, supplies, and training provided pursuant to section 1206 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2006 (Public Law 109–163; 119 Stat. 3456); and
any equipment, supplies, and training provided pursuant to section 1206 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2008 (Public Law 110–181; 122 Stat. 368).
Security forces of pakistan
The term security forces of Pakistan means the military and intelligence services of the Government of Pakistan, including the Armed Forces, Inter-Services Intelligence Directorate, Intelligence Bureau, police forces, levies, Frontier Corps, and Frontier Constabulary.
Major defense equipment
The term major defense equipment has the meaning given in section 47(6) of the Arms Export Control Act (22 U.S.C. 2794(6)).
Statement of policy
It is the policy of the United States—
to support the consolidation of democracy, good governance, and rule of law in Pakistan;
to support economic growth and development in order to promote stability and security across Pakistan;
to affirm and build a sustained, long-term, multifaceted relationship with Pakistan;
to further the sustainable economic development of Pakistan and the improvement of the living conditions of its citizens, including in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas, by expanding United States bilateral engagement with the Government of Pakistan, especially in areas of direct interest and importance to the daily lives of the people of Pakistan;
to work with Pakistan and the countries bordering Pakistan to facilitate peace in the region and harmonious relations between the countries of the region;
to work with the Government of Pakistan to prevent any Pakistani territory from being used as a base or conduit for terrorist attacks in Pakistan, Afghanistan, India, or elsewhere in the world;
to work in close cooperation with the Government of Pakistan to coordinate military, paramilitary, and police action against terrorist targets;
to work with the Government of Pakistan to help bring peace, stability, and development to all regions of Pakistan, especially those in the Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas, including support for an effective counterinsurgency strategy;
people-to-people engagement between the United States and Pakistan, through
increased educational, technical, and cultural exchanges and other
to encourage and
promote public-private partnerships in Pakistan in order to bolster ongoing
development efforts and strengthen economic prospects, especially with respect
to opportunities to build civic responsibility and professional skills of the
people of Pakistan
to encourage the development of local analytical capacity to measure progress on an integrated basis across the areas of donor country expenditure in Pakistan, and better hold the Government of Pakistan accountable for how the funds are being spent.
Authorization of funds
There are authorized to be appropriated to the President, for the purposes of providing assistance to Pakistan under the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (22 U.S.C. 2151 et seq.), the following amounts:
For fiscal year 2009, up to $1,500,000,000.
For fiscal year 2010, up to $1,500,000,000.
For fiscal year 2011, up to $1,500,000,000.
For fiscal year 2012, up to $1,500,000,000.
For fiscal year 2013, up to $1,500,000,000.
Funds Of the amounts
appropriated in each fiscal year pursuant to the authorization of appropriations in subsection (a)—
none of the
appropriated may be made available after the date of the enactment of this Act for assistance to Pakistan unless the Pakistan Assistance Strategy Report has been submitted to the appropriate congressional committees in accordance with subsection (j); and
not more than
may be made available for assistance to Pakistan in any fiscal year after 2009 unless the President’s Special Representative to Afghanistan and Pakistan submits to the appropriate congressional committees during that fiscal year—
that assistance provided to Pakistan under this Act to date has made or is making substantial progress toward achieving the principal objectives of United States assistance to Pakistan contained in the Pakistan Assistance Strategy Report pursuant to subsection (j)(1); and
reasons justifying the certification described in
(A). Maker of
Certification In the event
of a vacancy in, or the termination of, the position
of the President's Special Representative to Afghanistan and Pakistan, the
certification described under
(b) (2) may be made by
the Secretary of State.
The Secretary of State may waive the limitations in subsection (b) if the Secretary determines, and certifies to the appropriate congressional committees, that it is in the national security interests of the United States to provide such waiver.
Sense of Congress on foreign assistance funds
It is the sense of Congress that, subject to an improving political and economic climate in Pakistan, there should be authorized to be appropriated up to $1,500,000,000 per year for fiscal years 2014 through 2018 for the purpose of providing assistance to Pakistan under the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961.
Sense of Congress on security-related assistance
It is the sense of Congress that
security-related assistance to the
Government of Pakistan
should be provided in close coordination with the Government of Pakistan,
designed to improve the Government's capabilities in areas of mutual concern,
and maintained at a level that will bring significant gains in pursuing the
policies set forth in paragraphs (6), (7), and (8) of section
should be provided in close coordination with the Government of Pakistan, designed to improve the Government’s capabilities in areas of mutual concern, and maintained at a level that will bring significant gains in pursuing the policies set forth in paragraphs (6), (7), and (8) of section 4; and
should be geared primarily toward bolstering the counter-insurgency capabilities of the Government to effectively defeat the Taliban-backed insurgency and deny popular support to al Qaeda and other foreign terrorist organizations that are based in Pakistan.
Use of funds
Funds appropriated pursuant to subsection (a) shall be used for projects intended to benefit the people of Pakistan, including projects that promote—
just and democratic governance, including—
police reform, equipping, and training;
independent, efficient, and effective judicial systems;
political pluralism, equality, and the rule of law;
respect for human and civil rights and the promotion of an independent media;
transparency and accountability of all branches of government and judicial proceedings;
efforts among bureaucrats, elected officials, and public servants at all levels
of military and civilian government
and countering the narcotics
countering the narcotics trade; and
the implementation of legal and political reforms in the FATA;
economic freedom, including—
sustainable economic growth, including in rural areas, and the sustainable management of natural resources;
investments in energy and water, including energy generation and cross-border infrastructure projects with Afghanistan;
employment generation, including essential basic infrastructure projects such as roads and irrigation projects and other physical infrastructure; and
including the right to form labor unions and legally enforce provisions
safeguarding the rights of workers and local community
investments in people, particularly women and children, including—
broad-based public primary and secondary education and vocational training for both boys and girls;
food security and agricultural development to ensure food staples and other crops that provide economic growth and income opportunities in times of severe shortage;
health, including medical clinics with well trained staff serving rural and
vocational training for women and access to microfinance for small business establishment and income generation for women; and
to ensure a
breadth and consistency of Pakistani graduates to prepare citizens to help
strengthen the foundation for improved governance and economic vitality,
including through public-private partnerships
long-term development in regions of Pakistan where internal conflict has caused large-scale displacement.
Funding for police reform, equipping, and training
Up to $100,000,000 of the funds appropriated pursuant to subsection (a) should be used for police reform, equipping, and training.
Preference for building local capacity
The President is encouraged, as appropriate, to utilize Pakistani firms and community and local nongovernmental organizations in Pakistan, including through host country contacts, and to work with local leaders to provide assistance under this section.
Authority To use funds for operational and audit expenses
Of the amounts appropriated for a fiscal year pursuant to subsection (a)—
up to $10,000,000 may be used for administrative expenses of Federal departments and agencies in connection with the provision of assistance authorized by this section;
$20,000,000 may be made
available to the Inspectors General of the Department of State, the United
States Agency for International Development, and other relevant Executive
branch agencies in order to provide audits and program reviews of projects
funded pursuant to this section; and
up to $5,000,000 may be used by the Secretary to establish a Chief of Mission Fund for use by the Chief of Mission in Pakistan to provide assistance to Pakistan under the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (22 U.S.C. 2151 et seq.) to address urgent needs or opportunities, consistent with the purposes outlined in subsection (f) or for purposes of humanitarian relief.
Authority in addition to existing amounts
The amounts authorized under subparagraphs (A) and (B) of paragraph (1) to be used for the purposes described in such subparagraphs are in addition to other amounts that are available for such purposes.
Use of funds
Amounts appropriated or otherwise made available to carry out this section shall be utilized to the maximum extent possible as direct expenditures for projects and programs, subject to existing reporting and notification requirements.
Pakistan assistance strategy report
Not later than
days after the date of enactment of this Act, or September 15,
2009, whichever date comes later, the
President shall submit
to the appropriate congressional committees a report describing United States
policy and strategy with respect to assistance to Pakistan. The report shall
a description of the principal objectives of United States assistance to Pakistan to be provided under this Act;
the amounts of funds authorized to be appropriated under subsection (a) proposed to be allocated to programs or projects designed to achieve each of the purposes of assistance listed in subsection (f);
a description of the specific projects and programs for which amounts authorized to be appropriated pursuant to subsection (a) are proposed to be allocated;
a list of
criteria to be used to
measure the effectiveness of projects described under subsection (f), including
a systematic, qualitative basis
for assessing whether desired outcomes are achieved and a timeline for
completion of each project and program;
a description of
the role to be played by Pakistani national, regional, and local officials
in helping to identify and implement programs and
projects for which assistance is to be provided under this Act, and of
officials in developing the strategy ; and
a description of
all amounts made available for assistance to Pakistan during fiscal year 2009
prior to submission of the report, including a description of each project or
program for which funds were made available and the amounts allocated to each
such program or project
a description of the steps taken, or to be taken, to ensure assistance provided under this Act is not awarded to individuals or entities affiliated with terrorist organizations; and
a projection of
the levels of assistance to be provided to Pakistan under this Act, broken down
into the following categories as described in the annual
Report on the
Criteria and Methodology for Determining the Eligibility of Candidate Countries
for Millennium Challenge Account Assistance:
Voice and accountability.
Rule of law.
Control of corruption.
Public expenditure on health.
Girls’ primary education completion rate.
Public expenditure on primary education.
Natural resource management.
Land rights and access.
Notice of assistance for budget support
The President shall notify the appropriate congressional committees not later than 15 days before obligating any assistance under this section as budgetary support to the Government of Pakistan or any element of such Government and shall describe the purpose and conditions attached to any such budgetary support.
Not later than 90 days after the submission of the
Pakistan Assistance Strategy Report pursuant to subsection (j), and every 180
days thereafter, the
President shall submit
a report to the appropriate congressional committees that describes the
assistance provided under this section. The report shall include—
a description of all assistance provided pursuant to this Act since the submission of the last report, including each program or project for which assistance was provided and the amount of assistance provided for each program or project;
a description of all assistance provided pursuant to this Act, including—
the total amount of assistance provided for each of the purposes described in subsection (f); and
the total amount of assistance allocated to programs or projects in each region in Pakistan;
a list of persons
or entities from the United States or other countries that have received funds
in excess of
$250,000 to conduct projects
under this section during the period covered by the report, which may be
included in a classified annex, if necessary to avoid a security risk, and a
justification for the classification;
an assessment of the effectiveness of assistance provided pursuant to this Act during the period covered by the report in achieving desired objectives and outcomes, measured on the basis of the criteria contained in the Pakistan Assistant Strategy Report pursuant to subsection (j)(4);
a description of—
the programs and projects for which amounts appropriated pursuant to subsection (a) are proposed to be allocated during the 180-day period after the submission of the report;
the relationship of such programs and projects to the purposes of assistance described in subsection (f); and
the amounts proposed to be allocated to each such program or project;
a description of any shortfall in United States financial, physical, technical, or human resources that hinder the effective use and monitoring of such funds;
a description of any negative impact, including the absorptive capacity of the region for which the resources are intended, of United States bilateral or multilateral assistance and recommendations for modification of funding, if any;
any incidents or reports of waste, fraud, and abuse of expenditures under this section;
the amount of
funds appropriated pursuant to subsection (a) that were used during the
reporting period for administrative expenses or for audits and program reviews
pursuant to the authority under
a description of
the expenditures made from any Chief of Mission Fund established pursuant to
subsection (h)(3) during the period covered by the report, the purposes for
which such expenditures were made, and a list of the recipients of any
expenditures from the Chief of Mission Fund in excess of $10,000
an accounting of assistance provided to Pakistan under this Act, broken down into the categories set forth in subsection (j)(8).
Government Accountability Office Report
Not later than one year after the submission of the Pakistan Assistance Strategy Report under subsection (j), and annually thereafter, the Comptroller General of the United States shall submit to the appropriate congressional committees a report that contains—
a review of, and comments addressing, the Pakistan Assistance Strategy Report; and
recommendations relating to any additional actions the Comptroller General believes could help improve the efficiency and effectiveness of United States efforts to meet the objectives of this Act.
Sense of Congress on funding of priorities
It is the sense of Congress that, as a general principle, the Government of Pakistan should allocate a greater portion of its budget to the recurrent costs associated with education, health, and other priorities described in this section.
The President shall consult the appropriate congressional committees on the strategy in subsection (j), including criteria and benchmarks developed under paragraph (4) of such subsection, not later than 15 days before obligating any assistance under this section.
Limitation on certain assistance
Limitation on certain military assistance
Beginning in fiscal year 2010, no grant assistance to carry out section 23 of the Arms Export Control Act (22 U.S.C. 2763) and no assistance under chapter 2 of part II of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (22 U.S.C. 2311 et seq.) may be provided to Pakistan in a fiscal year until the Secretary of State makes the certification required under subsection (c).
Limitation on Arms transfers
Beginning in fiscal year 2012, no letter of offer to sell major defense equipment to Pakistan may be issued pursuant to the Arms Export Control Act (22 U.S.C. 2751 et seq.) and no license to export major defense equipment to Pakistan may be issued pursuant to such Act in a fiscal year until the Secretary of State makes the certification required under subsection (c).
The certification required by this subsection is a certification to the appropriate congressional committees by the Secretary of State, after consultation with the Secretary of Defense and the Director of National Intelligence, that the security forces of Pakistan—
consistent efforts to prevent al Qaeda and associated
terrorist groups, including Lashkar-e-Taiba and Jaish-e-Mohammed, from
operating in the territory of Pakistan;
consistent efforts to prevent the Taliban and associated
militant groups from using the territory of Pakistan as a sanctuary from which
to launch attacks within Afghanistan; and
are not materially interfering in the political or judicial processes of Pakistan.
The Secretary of State may waive the limitations in subsections (a) and (b) if the Secretary determines it is important to the national security interests of the United States to provide such waiver.
Prior notice of waiver
A waiver pursuant to subsection (d) may not be exercised until 15 days after the Secretary of State provides to the appropriate congressional committees written notice of the intent to issue such waiver and the reasons therefor. The notice may be submitted in classified or unclassified form, as necessary.
The Secretary of State, after consultation with the Secretary of Defense and the Director of National Intelligence, shall submit to the appropriate congressional committees an annual report on the progress of the security forces of Pakistan in satisfying the requirements enumerated in subsection (c). The Secretary of State shall establish detailed, specific requirements and metrics for evaluating the progress in satisfying these requirements and apply these requirements and metrics consistently in each annual report. This report may be submitted in classified or unclassified form, as necessary.
Sense of Congress on Coalition Support Funds
It is the sense of Congress that—
Coalition Support Funds are critical components of the global fight against terrorism, and in Pakistan provide essential support for—
military operations of the Government of Pakistan to destroy the terrorist threat and close the terrorist safe haven, known or suspected, in the FATA, the NWFP, and other regions of Pakistan; and
military operations of the Government of Pakistan to protect United States and allied logistic operations in support of Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan;
despite the broad discretion Congress granted the Secretary of Defense in terms of managing Coalition Support Funds, the Pakistan reimbursement claims process for Coalition Support Funds requires increased oversight and accountability, consistent with the conclusions of the June 2008 report of the United States Government Accountability Office (GAO–08–806);
in order to ensure that this significant United States effort in support of countering terrorism in Pakistan effectively ensures the intended use of Coalition Support Funds, and to avoid redundancy in other security assistance programs, such as Foreign Military Financing and Foreign Military Sales, more specific guidance should be generated, and accountability delineated, for officials associated with oversight of this program within the United States Embassy in Pakistan, the United States Central Command, the Department of Defense, the Department of State, and the Office of Management and Budget; and
the Secretary of Defense should submit to the appropriate congressional committees and the Committees on Armed Services of the Senate and the House of Representatives a semiannual report on the use of Coalition Support Funds, which may be submitted in classified or unclassified form as necessary.
Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas strategy
Development of comprehensive strategy
The Secretary of State, in consultation with the Secretary of Defense, the Director of National Intelligence, and such other government officials as may be appropriate, shall develop a comprehensive, cross-border strategy that includes all elements of national power—diplomatic, military, intelligence, development assistance, humanitarian, law enforcement support, and strategic communications and information technology—for working with the Government of Pakistan, the Government of Afghanistan, NATO, and other like-minded allies to best implement effective counterterrorism and counterinsurgency measurers in and near the Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas.
Not later than 90 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Secretary of State shall submit to the appropriate congressional committees a detailed description of a comprehensive strategy for counterterrorism and counterinsurgency in the Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas containing the elements specified in subsection (a) and proposed timelines and budgets for implementing the strategy.
Sense of Congress
It is the sense of Congress that the United States should—
recognize the bold political steps the Pakistan electorate has taken during a time of heightened sensitivity and tension in 2007 and 2008 to elect a new civilian government, as well as the continued quest for good governance and the rule of law under the elected government in 2008 and 2009;
seize this strategic opportunity in the interests of Pakistan as well as in the national security interests of the United States to expand its engagement with the Government and people of Pakistan in areas of particular interest and importance to the people of Pakistan;
continue to build
a responsible and reciprocal security relationship taking into account the
national security interests of the United States as well as regional and
national dynamics in Pakistan to further strengthen and enable the position of
Pakistan as a major non-NATO ally
seek ways to
strengthen our countries’ mutual understanding and promote greater insight and
knowledge of each other’s social, cultural and historical diversity through
personnel exchanges and support for the establishment of institutions of higher
learning with international accreditation
explore means to consult with and utilize the relevant expertise and skills of the Pakistani-American community.
Term of years
With the exception of subsections (b)(1)(B), (j), (k), and (l) of section 5, this Act shall remain in force after September 30, 2013.
June 23, 2009
Reported with amendments